Nikole Hannah-Jones’ essay questioning her decision to send her daughter to a high-poverty, predominantly Black and Hispanic school rocked the internet. People saw their own school experiences and parenting choices in her story. And they had thoughts!
Hannah-Jones is a Pulitzer Prize-winning journalist at the New York Times who writes about educational inequality. She came to Rochester in 2017 to speak specifically about school segregation and what it would take to build a more integrated educational system here.
I have often looked to her words to explain my advocacy for school integration, including metro schools. She has said that the reason to integrate schools is not because Black children cannot learn unless they are in the presence of white children; rather public education only works when the fates of all children are tied together. The social and economic capital of the “haves” should not be untangled from the “have nots.”
In our current system, parents with means often opt out of city public schools, whether by moving to the suburbs or paying for private schools.
Hannah-Jones decided not to opt out, and made an unusual choice — for a family that actually has choices — to send her child to a school middle class parents shunned. Jones wanted to live her values and strongly believed her family could help the school and its children through their means and advocacy.
Academically, It didn’t work. Her daughter fell way behind on math, something Hannah-Jones did not catch for years. Why? Because her kid was getting good grades. Her daughter thought she was doing well, until confronted with school rankings and the desire to go to a selective high school. The teenager wished her mom had made a different choice.
Devastating!
My social media feeds are filled with reactions to the article, including personal reflections, criticisms of Hannah-Jones, admiration for her courage, and acknowledgements of systemic educational failures. Many of the most painful responses I saw came from Black parents describing the impossible choices they face — if they have choices at all. They have to choose between high-performing and rigorous schools where their children may face racism or low-performing schools where their children may get cultural and emotional support, but struggle academically.
Not everyone carries the same weight of that inequality. But Hannah-Jones’ essay offers takeaways for everyone who is navigating these choices. As someone who attended RCSD and is now speaking with East District parents, I will share my own thoughts.
My Personal Experience
My parents were Rochester City School District educators. Like Hannah-Jones, they believed deeply in public education and sending their kids to city schools.
I attended School #7 until fourth grade, which was right in our Maplewood neighborhood. Back then, it was a mostly-white school. I walked to school with other kids. But I was bored that year; I just did not feel challenged. For fifth and sixth grade, my parents put me on a bus to School #50 for the Major Achievement Program (MAP).
School #50 sits next to a housing project for families with low incomes. My own classroom had fewer than 15 students. It was diverse, but majority white. The rest of the school was overwhelmingly Black and Hispanic, and the class sizes were large. Those two years at School #50 were the best of my K-12 years, but even then, I understood that I had special access to a very different experience.
The district got rid of 7-12 schools the year it was time for me to go into seventh grade. Charlotte Middle School was chaotic and violent. I enjoyed my classes and continued to excel, but I don’t remember much beyond long bus rides, crowded hallways and fighting.
Believe it or not, Marshall High School felt quite calm compared to Charlotte. I could walk to school again. I loved my teachers and classes; the school still offered honors and AP. But even as a teenager, I knew I had a close-up view of educational inequality. This was Rochester in the early ’90s, amid devastating levels of violence, teen pregnancy and poverty. I can name classmates who were killed. I can name those who went to prison.
Marshall had about 1,200 students in grades 9 through 12. I remember roughly 500 freshmen entering with me. On graduation night four years later, there were about 150 of us left.
My RCSD experience profoundly shaped my worldview — and my life. My parents sometimes expressed guilt, but I was an overachieving white kid who could go home to my middle-class life. My schools still offered special classes for honors kids. My teachers were wonderful. I did not experience racism, poverty or trauma. But I witnessed it — a lot of it.
Given this experience, I would never criticize a family for making different choices than my parents did. And as Hannah-Jones discovered, for many kids in high-poverty schools, even great parents are not enough to overcome what the system fails to provide.
What I’m Hearing from East District Parents
Since August, I’ve been knocking on doors across the East District and talking with Democratic voters about what matters to them. In hundreds of conversations, one of the issues that comes up most often — and produces some of the longest conversations — is city schools.
Here is what parents are saying. I should note that most of the parents I’ve spoken with so far are white and middle class, since I’m still working my way through the rest of the district.
They are deeply committed to public education and value diversity in classrooms.
They do not want to move to the suburbs to obtain educational opportunities for their children. They do not want their neighbors to move, either.
The RCSD parents I’ve spoken with are generally very satisfied with the education their own children are getting. Their children are usually attending higher-performing schools, and those same parents express deep concern about inequality across the district. They also worry about opportunities available when their kids reach high school.
Parents whose children have graduated from RCSD are pleased with the education their children have received and the adults they’ve become.
I am grateful for every person who took the time to share their honest and heartfelt feelings about the state of city schools and their own choices.
Listening to them, I felt like I could have been talking to my parents 40 years ago. The fact that families are still wrestling with the same choices is an enormous failure.
You may be wondering how a county legislator and potential City Councilmember responds to these parents. Everyone knows we don’t control RCSD. But I refuse to believe elected officials should sit on the sidelines when family after family is telling us they want to stay in the city, invest in public education and have confidence that every child can get a good education.
I don’t know what leadership on this issue looks like, but the first step is listening and telling our stories. I had already spoken with a school board member about what I was hearing at doors, and I had already planned to write some version of this essay later in the fall. But then Hannah-Jones got the world talking.
Hannah-Jones writes with regret, but I don’t read her essay as a repudiation of the case she has made for years. Her original premise remains true: Separate is not equal.
What her family’s experience demonstrates is how much we have asked individual parents to carry the burden of a systemic failure. We cannot expect families to solve school segregation one child at a time while leaving intact the segregation and concentrated poverty that put them in this position.
Shannon Watts Fundraiser
We have added an in-person component to this fundraiser for my City Council campaign. Shannon is a Rochester native and founder emerita of Moms Demand Action. We’ll talk local and national politics. Join us at Salena’s — appetizers will be provided. Buy tickets here.



Rachel are you familiar with Rochester Early College? Best kept secret in the RCSD - if you haven’t check it out sometime
I read these stories over and over about the city schools and there is one huge thing that is missing. The systemic problem is not just within city schools, it’s the entire system. City schools are most affected because our system especially fails lower income and single parent households. But the same problems exist in the suburbs. Integrated schools will not fix the issue, it will only geographicllay spread out the pain felt by a failed educational model and mostly the same people will be affected. That's just the conclusion based on my experiences.