Discussion about this post

User's avatar
DonWegeng's avatar

A couple thoughts:

- Electricity

In other parts of the country, data centers are generating their own power rather than using power from the grid. This can be a bad option, but it doesn't have to be. One option is to use hydrogen fuel cells to supply the electricity, which by happy coincidence Rochester already has local expertise in this area. PlugPower, which has local facilities, has recently released a webinar on this topic.

https://www.plugpower.com/webinar-reducing-grid-strain-and-supporting-operational-growth-with-fuel-cells/

It's no surprise that STREAM doesn't want to investing it's own money in power generation when RG&E will happily sell them the electricity, but that's not a good reason to burden rate payers with extra costs.

- Water

As with electricity, STREAM obviously doesn't want to invest it's own money to provide water when the Monroe County Water Authority will sell them water. But it's interesting that STREAM doesn't plan to use water to cool the servers in this proposed facility. I'm going to speculate that they are not going to use water either because 1) MCWA can't provide them with sufficient quantities of water, and / or 2) the water that MCWA can provide isn't cold enough.

Those of us with good memories will recall that there have been previous efforts to use Lake Ontario water to provide cooling. Xerox investigated this back in the 1990's, and the Town of Webster initiated another study in the early 2010's. I don't know why this was never implemented, but I will guess that a curious member of the county legislature could find out. Those studies were focused on using lake water to chill (air condition) facilities, but a similar concept can be used to chill computer servers. Here's an article about the more recent effort.

https://www.democratandchronicle.com/story/news/2014/06/30/webster-lake-ontario-cold-industry/11798879/

Assuming that the barrier to using Lake Ontario water to chill a data center located at STAMP is supply and/or water temperature, one must wonder if STAMP is the wrong location for STREAM's data center. Perhaps Webster or another location closer to Lake Ontario would be a better choice.

Douglas Larson's avatar

Hold that moratorium and stop this project. Just this fact "GCEDC earns fees from the project, potentially more than $140 million, so it has incentive to approve the tax breaks and environmental clearance." Should be enough to tell you to stop it. Who are the ones getting rich at the GCEDC? This is the real question that will probably stop this very quickly.

9 more comments...

No posts

Ready for more?